. . . Applies scientific
disciplines to physical evidence
"People have often said, `Oh, you're like
Sam on the TV show Quincy,'" says Mark Farley,
formerly a forensic chemist with New York's Suffolk
County division of medical-legal services. "But
forensic chemists hardly ever do investigative
work like Quincy does. They handle evidence picked
up from the scene of the crime."
Susan Ragudo, forensic chemist with the Commonwealth
of Virginia, Division of Forensic Science, echoes.
"Certainly in my job as a forensic chemist,
I am not trained at all to go out and deal with
the criminals. I come to work, I do my work in
the laboratory, and then I leave and go home.
I don't do any of the investigating work like
Quincy does."
A forensic chemist is, in general, somebody who
analyzes evidence that's brought in from crime
scenes and determines a conclusion based on tests
run on that piece of evidence. A forensic chemist's
job is to identify the evidence as part of the
larger process of solving a crime. Ragudo specializes
in drug chemistry but evidence brought into other
labs can include paint chips, human hair, glass
fragments, blood stains, or soil, to name a few.
When evidence is brought in from a crime scene,
Ragudo runs a series of tests-preliminary screening
tests such as color tests; a series of chromatography
tests to see if more than one drug is present;
and GC/MS to identify a controlled substance.
"It's kinds of neat when you have something
that's an unknown and you're determining what
it is," says Ragudo.
"Forensic chemists are experts in the reconstruction
of events in the most basic form," says Mary
Gibbons, director of the Oakland Police Department
Crime Lab in Oakland, CA. "We
apply scientific disciplines to problems that
present themselves in the form of physical evidence."
Understanding the evidence requires tools from
many disciplines, including chemistry, biology,
materials science, and genetics. In fact, the
prevalence of DNA analysis is making knowledge
of genetics increasingly important in this field.
. . . putting together pieces of the puzzle
"In forensic science, you can't control your
sample material; you have to play the card someone
else deals you," says Kurt Dubowski, George
Lynn Cross distinguished professor of medicine
and director of the forensic science lab at the
University of Oklahoma. Farley describes this
aspect of the job as `putting together the pieces
of a puzzle.' Ragudo adds, "You're trying
to help put pieces together to see if a crime
was committed and who did it."
. . . Explaining and defending your work
Forensic chemists agree that public speaking skills
and being comfortable with what you do are important
personal characteristics for this career. "You
have to be articulate and comfortable explaining
complicated things in simple ways," says
Gibbons. Ragudo comments, "Sometimes we're
needed to explain to the jury what we do, what
we found, and how we came to our conclusion. All
we're doing when we go to court is testifying
to what we found. We don't work for either the
prosecution or the defense so we have nothing
to hide from either side. But it can be a little
disturbing to get up in front of a judge or jury
and explain what you do. You have to be comfortable
enough with what you do to explain it to someone,
and you can't get annoyed very easily if defense
attorneys try to get to get under your skin. Sometimes
defense attorneys try to discredit us by saying
that our tests are invalid just to make their
client look okay in the jury's eyes."
Farley points to one case in which he analyzed
a sample found in the pocket of a man charged
with selling LSD. The suspect claimed the sample
was mescaline, says Farley, explaining that a
conviction for selling mescaline carries a lighter
sentence. "I analyzed the material and confirmed
it was LSD. Later, in court, I had to explain
my analysis to the jury and describe the difference
between the two drugs." In another case,
Farley was asked to verify evidence found on a
suspect as quaalude tablets. His analysis revealed
the sample was aspirin. "What the suspect
was carrying in this case was not illegal. The
police weren't too happy about that," he
says, "but I had to stand by my analysis.
You also have to remain impartial," warns
Farley. "It's your job to analyze the evidence,
not to judge."
Not all cases go to trial, but when one does,
giving expert testimony in court is a significant
piece of a forensic chemist's job. Some employers
require their forensic chemists to go through
several months of mock courtroom testimony training
during their regular training. "If you enjoy
teaching, you may be well suited for the court
aspects of this work," says Gibbons. "You
need to teach the jury about your analysis and
your findings, explain the basis of your opinion,
and help them make a decision."
Forensic science is an environment in which everything
is visible, from the collection of materials to
the final report. Farley explains, "You have
to document your work in exquisite detail. Often,
you must present and explain your work in court,
and be ready to defend your results, and face
scrutiny of your personal qualifications and technical
competence."
. . . Offers various opportunities
The career path for most forensic chemists is
through federal, state and county labs associated
with the medical examiner's office. However, there
are different types of careers available with
forensic chemistry, including those in other fields
of forensic science. Chemists can also move up
within a particular section. For example, as director
of the Oakland Crime Lab, Gibbons supervises other
forensic scientists rather than being involved
in day-to-day analysis. She is also responsible
for case review and general lab management. Dubowski's
career-long focus on behavioral toxicology has
taken his work into research, the development
of analytic procedures, and teaching. Farley transferred
his technical training to the field of patent
law.
All three say the aspect of forensic chemistry
they enjoy most is the challenge of new projects
and applying their scientific knowledge to a unique
set of problems every day.
Copyright 1997 American Chemical Society
WORK DESCRIPTION
Forensic scientists apply knowledge from diverse
disciplines such as chemistry, biology, materials
science, and genetics to the analysis of evidence
found at crime scenes or on/in the body of a crime
suspect. The field is a combination of criminalistics
and analytical toxicology. Criminalistics is the
qualitative examination of evidence using methods
such as microscopy and spot testing, while analytical
toxicology looks for evidence in body fluids through
a range of instrumental techniques from optical
methods (UV, infrared, x-ray) to separations analyses
such as gas chromatography, HPLC, and thin layer
chromatography. Most often, forensic chemists
do not know the nature of the sample before they
analyze it. The results of their work are used
in police investigations and court trials where
they may be called upon to provide expert testimony
and explain their findings to a jury.
WORKING CONDITIONS
Forensic scientists generally work in government
labs which can be small, understaffed, and underfunded.
They spend time preparing and giving testimony
in court. Formerly under the jurisdiction of the
police department, forensics has traditionally
been totally male dominated. However, over the
last 15 years, the field has opened up to women
who are moving up in its ranks.
PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT
Most labs are associated with a federal, state,
or local police department, medical examiner's
office, forensic services lab, or branch of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation. There are some
private labs which carry out forensic analysis,
but they rare.
PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS
Versatility and patience are the most often cited
qualities of a forensic scientist. Forensic chemists
must be able to spend hours rigorously applying
analytical techniques to evidence, and then defending
their work in a court of law. They must be able
to clearly and concisely answer challenges to
their findings. Integrity is also an important
characteristic because it is not unusual for the
different interests in a case to try and sway
the forensic chemist's position.
EDUCATION AND TRAINING
A strong background in chemistry, instrumental
analysis, and a good grounding in criminalistics
are vital. A forensic science degree at both the
undergraduate and graduate level is recommended.
If interested in working with trace evidence such
as glass, hair, and paper, focus on instrumentation
skills and take courses in geology, soil chemistry,
and materials science. If forensic biology and
DNA analysis are preferred, take microbiology,
genetics, and biochemistry courses. Those interested
in the toxicological aspects of this work should
study physiology, biochemistry, and chemistry.
JOB OUTLOOK
The forensic science field is guardedly optimistic
about job prospects for the future. Greater interest
in the use of DNA analysis is expected to create
more jobs. Those interested in DNA work should
keep up with the rapidly changing technology and
develop skills that distinguish them from the
pack.
SALARY RANGE
For chemists, incomes start in the low $30,000-per-year
range. The median salary is $40,000. Chemists
at the high end are paid around $60,000-per-year.
Scientists involved with fingerprint analysis
are on the lower end of the pay scale.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Contact schools with academic programs in forensic
science. University of New Haven, George Washington
University and City University of New York all
have graduate programs. Michigan State University
has programs on the graduate and undergraduate
level.
WHAT YOU CAN DO NOW
Contact local forensics labs and find out when
a forensic scientist will be testifying in court.
Going to see them testify will give you a sense
of whether this aspect of the work is right for
you. Hands-on technical experience is more difficult
to get. Most labs do not have internships, but
may take on volunteers. Academic requirements
are tightening. Give thought to graduate work
and research projects that show you are capable
of problem solving. To prepare for court presentations,
scientists recommend participation in the debate
team and school theater.
American Chemical Society, Education Division,
1155 Sixteenth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20036;
(202) 452-2113. Production of career material
was funded by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
|